Effective June 1, 2015, the federal states were granted the option to limit rent increases for new leases of existing residential units to 15 percent. The benchmark is the “local comparative rent” listed in the rent index for the respective city. Newly constructed buildings and extensively renovated properties are expressly excluded from this provision. North Rhine-Westphalia has announced the cap for 22 municipalities. (The state has already stated that it does not intend to make use of the option to extend the measure.)
The relevant law was tightened effective January 1, 2019, and October 1, 2019: Rent increases are now limited to 10% of the comparable rent, and any previously imposed unlawful rent increase may be reclaimed.
It is undisputed that, due to a variety of circumstances, there is a shortage of housing in terms of quantity, size, and location. This observation is particularly true for highly sought-after locations, price ranges, and cities—such as Berlin, for example. There, past mistakes must also be corrected by repurchasing housing stock from municipal companies that was sold off recklessly.
To change this, politicians have come up with ideas that initially focus on housing pricing. Probably because this is quick, costs nothing, and looks good to the public… but it does nothing to address the actual cause—the shortage of housing units… there is simply a shortage of hundreds of thousands of apartments that have not been built because there is no incentive for investors and developers.
A rent cap won’t magically create a single additional apartment—on the contrary, potential builders of the desired housing will seek and find other ways to use their capital. If the rental market doesn’t allow for a sensible—that is, profitable—investment, condominiums and single-family homes will be built. This also has the invaluable advantage of being able to realize a profit immediately upon sale.
It is easy to see that the actual goal has clearly been missed. Nor will extending the law’s duration or expanding it to additional cities and regions lead to success.
A scarce product does not become more abundant simply by capping its price.
The additional rent cap announced by the state of Berlin could—according to legal experts—conflict with existing laws, since the federal government has already established regulations limiting rent increases for new leases. Experts note that an individual state cannot impose additional regulations on the same matter—it lacks the regulatory authority to do so.
Rental housing accounts for a mere 54% of the total housing stock in Germany! In all other European countries, the homeownership rate is much higher. Here, lawmakers can make a meaningful difference by creating framework conditions that enable those who are “currently—still—tenants” to purchase their own homes.